X

After 40 Years, Police Finally Identify Black Woman Found Buried in a Basement

Nationwide — A Tennessee woman whose remains were found buried in a Nashville basement nearly 40 years ago has finally been identified. Police have finally confirmed that the woman was Toni L. Gordon, one of two murder victims discovered in 1987. Her identification also gives her family long-awaited answers about what happened to her.

The Nashville Metropolitan Police Department announced Monday that investigators used forensic genetic genealogy to identify Gordon, who was 31 years old when she died. For decades, detectives knew her only as “Lil’ Bit,” a nickname used by the man responsible for her death. Despite years of investigation, authorities were unable to determine her identity until now.

According to People, investigators believe Gordon and 23-year-old Sheila Cummings were killed in 1985. Their remains were discovered two years later in shallow graves beneath the dirt floor of a basement at a Nashville home. The property had previously been rented by James Shaffer, who was arrested shortly after police found the bodies.

Shaffer confessed to killing both women following the discovery, police said. He was later sentenced to two life terms for the murders. However, investigators continued working to identify the victims, particularly the woman they knew only as “Lil’ Bit.” Shaffer died in prison in 2004, but the investigation into Gordon’s identity remained open.

Police identified Cummings in 2025, leaving Gordon as the last of the two victims to be named. Investigators eventually used forensic genetic genealogy to establish her identity. The technique combines DNA testing with family history research to identify unknown individuals through genetic connections to relatives. It has helped law enforcement agencies revisit cold cases and identify human remains that have gone unidentified for years.

Gordon’s family previously believed she had moved out of state. They eventually lost contact with her and did not know she had been killed, according to police. Detectives have since notified her relatives of the identification. Nashville police also credited several organizations for their assistance throughout the nearly four-decade investigation, including DNA Investigative Solutions, Bode Technology, the National Missing & Unidentified Persons System, the Davidson County Medical Examiner’s Office and the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation.

X

Headline

You can control the ways in which we improve and personalize your experience. Please choose whether you wish to allow the following:

Privacy Settings